For more than a century, America’s favorite dogs have told a story about who we are and how we live. From the hardworking farm dogs of the early 1900s to today’s apartment-friendly companions, the shifting popularity of dog breeds reflects our changing lifestyles, cultural moments, and evolving relationship with our canine companions.
The Early Years: Working Dogs Reign Supreme (1900s-1920s)
At the dawn of the 20th century, the Collie topped the popularity charts throughout the 1900s, long before Lassie captured hearts on screen. These herding dogs excelled at farm work and were valued for their intelligence and trainability—essential qualities when agriculture dominated American life.
The 1910s marked a turning point with the rise of the Boston Terrier, proudly nicknamed “The American Gentleman.” The Boston Terrier became the first small companion dog to reach the number-one position, signaling an early shift toward breeds valued more for companionship than labor. This all-American creation, developed by crossing English Bulldogs with white English Terriers, represented something new: a dog bred specifically for the rising middle class.
Hollywood’s influence on dog ownership became evident in the 1920s when the German Shepherd claimed first place in 1925, thanks largely to the widespread popularity of Rin Tin Tin, a war hero dog who starred in 27 films. This marked one of the first times that pop culture dramatically influenced breed popularity—a trend that continues today.
Economic Hardship and Practical Choices (1930s-1940s)
The Great Depression brought a return to smaller, more economical breeds. The Boston Terrier reclaimed its crown in the early 1930s before giving way to the Cocker Spaniel, which dominated the 1940s. These compact dogs required less food and space—practical considerations during difficult economic times.
The Cocker Spaniel’s rise to prominence was boosted by a celebrity dog of its own: My Own Brucie, who won Best in Show at Westminster in both 1940 and 1941, becoming one of the most photographed dogs in the world. The breed’s cheerful temperament and manageable size made it ideal for families looking for affordable companionship.
The Suburban Era and Pop Culture Influence (1950s-1980s)
The 1950s brought home ownership and suburban living, perfectly suited for the Beagle, which claimed the top spot. Charles Schultz’s Snoopy made his first appearance on October 4, 1950, and the beloved cartoon character helped cement the Beagle’s place in American hearts.
Then came the Poodle era. Poodles ascended to the number one spot in 1960 and stayed there until 1981—an unprecedented two-decade reign. The breed’s intelligence, versatility in size (toy, miniature, and standard), and success in dog shows made it the perfect companion for the era. Poodle skirts weren’t the only place these curly-coated dogs appeared; they dominated fashion magazines and became status symbols among celebrities.
The 1980s saw the gentle Cocker Spaniel return to the top spot, possibly buoyed by the enduring popularity of Disney’s “Lady and the Tramp,” which had premiered in 1955 but continued to capture new generations of dog lovers.
The Retriever Revolution (1990s-2022)
Nothing in dog breed history compares to the Labrador Retriever’s dominance. The Lab was previously the most popular breed in the U.S. for 31 straight years, from 1991 until 2022. This remarkable run reflected America’s love affair with family-friendly, versatile dogs that could adapt to any lifestyle—from hiking companion to therapy dog to beloved family pet.
The Lab’s popularity was reinforced by pop culture moments like the movie “Marley & Me” and television shows featuring retrievers. Their friendly nature, intelligence, and adaptability made them the default answer when Americans thought about getting a dog.
The Modern Era: Small Dogs and Designer Breeds (2020s)
The 2020s have ushered in dramatic changes. The French Bulldog continues to top the rankings at the No. 1 spot for the third year in a row, finally dethroning the Labrador Retriever in 2022. This shift reflects profound changes in how Americans live.
With urbanization accelerating and apartment living becoming more common, smaller breeds have surged in popularity. In recent years, the size of the average U.S. apartment has decreased, leaving many families with less than 900 square feet of living space. The French Bulldog, requiring minimal exercise and grooming, thrives in these compact spaces.
Designer breeds have also exploded in popularity. Non designer mixed breeds are the most popular dog breed in America, followed by the Labrador Retriever and Goldendoodle. These intentional crosses, like Goldendoodles and Maltipoos, combine desirable traits from both parent breeds, often emphasizing hypoallergenic coats and temperament over pedigree.
The shift toward mixed breeds also reflects changing attitudes about pet adoption, with shelter dogs finding homes more readily than in previous decades.
Breeds on the Rise
While French Bulldogs dominate, other breeds are climbing rapidly. The Kerry Blue Terrier had the highest jump, moving up a whopping 25 spots from No. 160 to No. 135 in recent rankings. The Cane Corso has seen particularly impressive growth, advancing from 47th place in 2014 to 14th in 2024—a 414% increase that suggests Americans’ growing interest in larger, protective breeds.
The Miniature Poodle is the top-trending breed of 2024, up 12%, perhaps indicating a return to classic breeds that fit modern lifestyles.
What Drives Breed Popularity?
Several factors consistently influence which breeds capture America’s attention:
Pop Culture Impact: From Rin Tin Tin to Snoopy to the viral dogs of Instagram, media representation powerfully shapes breed preferences. Movies, television shows, and now social media can catapult relatively unknown breeds into the spotlight.
Lifestyle Changes: Urbanization, smaller living spaces, and changing work patterns (including remote work) have made adaptable, lower-maintenance breeds more appealing.
Health and Hypoallergenic Qualities: The rise of designer breeds like Goldendoodles reflects growing interest in dogs suitable for people with allergies.
Celebrity Influence: When public figures showcase specific breeds, registrations often surge—a phenomenon dubbed the “celebrity effect.”
Economic Factors: Historical patterns show that during economic downturns, smaller, less expensive breeds tend to gain popularity.
Personality Over Pedigree: 61% of pet parents chose their dog based on the assumed characteristics of their breed or breed mix, rather than appearance. Loyalty, friendliness, and playfulness rank as the most desired traits.
Looking Ahead
As we move further into the 21st century, breed popularity will likely continue reflecting our changing world. Remote work may increase demand for breeds requiring more attention and exercise. Climate change could influence preferences based on dogs’ heat tolerance. Advances in genetic testing allow owners to better understand their mixed-breed dogs’ heritage and potential health issues.
One thing remains constant: our enduring love for dogs themselves. Whether a purebred show champion or a mixed-breed rescue, the most popular dog in any household is always the one waiting at the door with a wagging tail. The evolution of breed popularity tells us less about dogs themselves and more about the ever-changing story of human life—and how our four-legged companions fit into it.
From farm workers to Instagram stars, from Collies to French Bulldogs, dogs have adapted to every era while helping us adapt to ours. That’s a trend that shows no signs of changing.
Visit The Dog API to vote on all the great dog photos.
